Can a Landlord Break a Fixed-Term Lease in Australia?


Being a landlord is not always a smooth ride, especially when it comes to navigating the intricate rules surrounding fixed-term leases. So, can a landlord break a fixed-term lease in Australia, and what are the consequences?

A Closer Look at a Fixed-Term Lease

When you, as a landlord, sign up for a fixed-term lease with your tenant, you’re essentially entering into a legal agreement that is binding for a set amount of time. 

Often ranging from six months to a few years, these leases provide a sense of security for both parties. You know your property is occupied and generating rent, while the tenant can rest easy, knowing they have a place to call home for the agreed-upon period. 

However, unexpected circumstances can strike at any time, leading to questions like, “Can a landlord break a fixed-term lease?” Before we delve into the conditions under which you might be able to terminate the lease early, let’s understand some basics. 

  • Fixed-term agreement: This is a rental agreement where the tenant agrees to stay and pay rent for the period of time indicated in the contract, instead of a periodic tenancy. During this time, the rental terms can’t be altered unless either party violates the terms or conditions clearly set out in the lease.
  • Break clause: Some leases may have a break clause that allows either the tenant or the landlord to terminate the contract before the end of the fixed term, given certain circumstances. This must be mutually agreed upon and stated clearly in the lease.
  • Lease termination: This generally requires a legal reason, such as a breach of contract or condition issues. Seeking legal counsel if you’re considering imposing a termination date is essential.

Can a Landlord Legally Terminate a Fixed Term Lease Early?

As a landlord, one question that might be tossing around in your mind is: “Can I terminate a fixed-term lease early?” Well, the answer isn’t actually a straightforward one. 

The circumstances around lease termination vary, and Australian tenant and lease laws hold different provisions for lease termination. 

The Residential Tenancies Act (RTA), Australia’s tenant and lease law, mostly leans towards the tenant’s rights. The Act acknowledges that there might be reasons a landlord would need to terminate a fixed-term lease early, but these reasons must be valid and dire. These include: 

  • Severe damage to the property
  • The tenant is using the property for illegal activities
  • The tenant breaches the agreement
  • A domestic violence termination notice is involved
  • The tenant is often late or never pays rent for the rented premises.

Notably, landlords can decide to sell their property at any time, provided they work with the tenant to ensure a smooth and fair transition.

However, remember that following due process is essential when you decide to end a tenancy agreement early. You should issue the tenant with a ‘Notice to Vacate,’ which should state your reasons for lease termination and should be served within the required legal timeframe. 

It’s also important to note that tenants can dispute their reasons for lease termination through Consumer Affairs Victoria or the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal. So, preparing and presenting verifiable proof or evidence for the termination is crucial. 

Remember, breaking a lease shouldn’t be a shallow decision, but a measured action taken only under specific circumstances. And while it may mean bearing certain financial implications, following the law can save you from future legal hassles.

Tips on Negotiating Early Termination of Lease

As a landlord, initiating an early termination of a lease could be troublesome. Taking a fair and communicative approach is essential to make the process smooth:

  • Open Communication: Like in any relationship, open and honest dialogue is key about the tenancy agreement and intended termination date. Share your rationale for the lease termination with your tenant, ensuring the conversation takes place face-to-face or via phone for a personalised touch.
  • Be Fair: No tenant enjoys eviction. Hence, ensure they are compensated for any inconvenience. This could mean arranging and financing their removal costs and/or contributing to a replacement property’s rental costs.
  • Negotiate: Try negotiating the issue that’s making you want to end the lease. For instance, if a tenant’s behaviour is causing problems, it might be possible to agree on a behavioural change before lease termination becomes necessary.
  • Provide Adequate Notice: Make sure you give your tenant immediate notice and put the minimum notice period in writing. Go above and beyond what’s detailed in the lease or the law. This will help them prepare and find a new property in good time. 
  • Document Everything: This can’t be emphasised enough – have a written record of all conversations, negotiations, and agreed-upon steps. These documents will help protect you if you end up facing any legal strife down the line. This goes for the periodic agreement as well.

It’s also good practice to seek legal advice before trying to end a lease early. An attorney can guide you through the legalities, ensuring you carry out the process correctly and in a way that won’t harm your interests.

Landlord’s Responsibilities When Ending a Lease Early

As a landlord, ending a fixed-term lease early might seem daunting, but it’s important to remember that you have responsibilities too. Managing these dutifully helps you avoid legal consequences and maintains a good relationship with your tenants. 

Firstly, communication is key. Ensure that your tenant knows the situation and give them sufficient notice. This should be done in writing, to provide a record of this communication. 

  • The notice period will depend on the specific terms of the lease and on the state legislation. In general, you should give at least 30 days notice.
  • If you’re unsure about the required notice period, seeking legal advice is a good idea.

Secondly, you should be fair and reasonable in your approach when it comes to providing the termination notice. Remember you’re affecting someone’s lifestyle and livelihood, so you should always offer a mutual termination agreement, in which both parties agree to end the lease early. 

You should also offer some form of compensation to the tenant, such as refunding rent or offering to cover the cost of their relocation. 

How much notice you give beyond the minimum legally required is entirely up to you.

Remember, the goal is to handle the early termination of the lease in a way that respects both your needs and those of your tenant. So be patient, be reasonable, and stay informed. 

Key Takeaways

  • Understanding the essentials of a fixed-term lease is vital for landlords.
  • A landlord can legally terminate a fixed-term lease in certain circumstances.
  • Legal guidance can be necessary when considering lease termination.
  • Effective negotiation techniques can facilitate early termination without undue harm to either party.
  • Landlords have responsibilities to fulfil when ending a lease early to ensure a smooth transition.

Ready to get insured?

Our friendly staff are ready to answer any questions.